Handling Commission Requests for Gallery Artists: A Practical Guide
You just got an email. It’s from a collector who saw your piece at the gallery, loved it, and wants to know if you take commissions. Your heart skips a beat. This is great news-someone actually wants to buy original work directly from you. But then the panic sets in. How do you price it? What if they hate the sketch? Who owns the copyright? If you’re an artist represented by a gallery, handling commissions isn’t just about drawing; it’s about managing expectations, protecting your rights, and keeping your relationship with your dealer healthy.
Most artists treat commissions as side gigs that happen in a vacuum. That’s a mistake. When you have gallery representation, every transaction affects your brand value and your dealer’s inventory strategy. You need a system. Here is how to navigate the messy, exciting world of commissioned art without losing your mind or your money.
The Gatekeeper Role: Why Your Gallery Matters
First, let’s clear up a common misconception. Just because a client asks you directly doesn’t mean you should bypass your gallery. In fact, doing so can create friction. Your gallery invests in your career through marketing, exhibition costs, and sales efforts. They expect a return on that investment, usually via a commission split (typically 50/50, though it varies).
If you sell a commission privately, you might save on the split, but you risk alienating your dealer. Worse, you might undercut your own market price. Galleries set prices based on consistency. If you charge a private buyer $500 less than the gallery price because you didn’t want to deal with paperwork, you’ve effectively lowered your market value for everyone else.
So, what’s the move? Always loop your gallery in early. Most dealers are happy to handle the administrative heavy lifting if it means they get their cut. Frame it as a partnership. Tell the client, “I’d love to discuss this. My gallery handles all my professional transactions to ensure everything is documented correctly. I’ll copy them on our emails.” This makes you look professional and protects your relationship with both parties.
Defining the Scope Before You Pick Up a Brush
The biggest source of pain in commissions is scope creep. You agree to paint a portrait. Then the client says, “Could you add a dog?” Then, “Actually, can the background be sunset orange instead of blue?” Suddenly, you’re doing three times the work for the same pay.
To avoid this, you need a detailed brief. Don’t rely on vague descriptions like “make it feel cozy.” Ask specific questions:
- Dimensions: Exact height and width in inches or centimeters.
- Medium: Oil, acrylic, watercolor, digital? Specify the surface (canvas, paper, panel).
- Subject Matter: Who or what is being depicted? Provide reference photos.
- Color Palette: Are there colors to include or exclude?
- Deadline: When do they need the finished piece?
- Usage Rights: Will they use the image for commercial purposes (like a book cover) or just hang it in their living room?
Write these down in a simple document or email thread. Get their confirmation. If they change their mind later, you have proof of the original agreement. This isn’t about being difficult; it’s about clarity.
Pricing Your Work Correctly
Pricing commissions is tricky because it’s not just about materials and hours. It’s about opportunity cost. Every hour you spend on a commission is an hour you aren’t spending on new work for your next gallery show. If you underprice, you’re essentially paying the client for the privilege of painting for them.
A solid formula for gallery-represented artists looks like this:
- Base Price: Start with the retail price of a similar-sized piece in your current portfolio. This maintains market consistency.
- Complexity Adjustment: Add 10-20% if the subject is complex (e.g., multiple figures, intricate patterns).
- Rush Fee: If they need it faster than your standard 4-8 week turnaround, add 25-50%.
- Revisions: Include one round of minor revisions. Charge extra for major changes after approval.
Remember, your gallery will likely take their percentage from the final sale price. Factor that into your quote. If you need $2,000 net, and your split is 50%, quote $4,000. Never quote a net number unless you explicitly state, “This is my net fee; please add gallery commission.”
The Contract: Non-Negotiable Protection
Handshakes don’t hold up in court, and they rarely hold up when a client is unhappy. You need a written agreement. It doesn’t need to be fifty pages long. A one-page contract covers the basics:
| Clause | Why It Matters | Example Value |
|---|---|---|
| Deposit | Secures commitment and covers materials | 50% upfront |
| Payment Schedule | Ensures cash flow during creation | 50% upon completion/shipping |
| Copyright | Artist retains reproduction rights | Client gets physical ownership only |
| Cancellation | Protects time invested | Non-refundable deposit |
Crucially, specify that copyright remains with the artist unless otherwise stated in writing. The client buys the physical object, not the right to put your painting on t-shirts or mugs without asking. This distinction saves you headaches down the road.
Managing Client Expectations During Creation
Once the contract is signed and the deposit is in, the real work begins. Communication is key here. Don’t go silent for six weeks. Send progress updates. A quick photo of the underpainting or a sketch keeps the client engaged and prevents surprises.
However, set boundaries on feedback. Decide beforehand how many rounds of revisions are included. For example, “Two rounds of minor adjustments before final varnish.” After that, changes cost extra. This stops the endless cycle of “Can we try it slightly darker?”
Be honest about delays. Art takes time. Drying times for oils, waiting for custom frames, or shipping logistics can push dates. If you think you’ll miss a deadline, tell the client immediately. Surprises breed distrust; transparency builds loyalty.
Shipping and Presentation
The final impression matters. How the artwork arrives is part of the product. If you’re shipping, factor in crating costs. Custom crates are expensive but safe. Bubble wrap alone often fails for large canvases.
Coordinate with your gallery on shipping. Sometimes, they prefer the piece goes through their office for inspection and invoicing. Other times, direct-to-client is fine. Clarify who pays for shipping. Usually, the client does, but you should provide a quote beforehand. Use insured carriers like FedEx or UPS with tracking. Never ship without insurance.
Include a certificate of authenticity. This small card adds perceived value and helps the client prove provenance if they ever resell the piece. Sign it, date it, and include a high-resolution photo of the work.
When Things Go Wrong
Not every commission ends happily. Maybe the client hates the color. Maybe they claim it doesn’t match the sketch. Since you had a contract and regular updates, you’re protected. Refer back to the approved sketches and emails. “We agreed on this palette in March,” is a powerful reminder.
If the dispute persists, involve your gallery. Dealers are skilled negotiators and mediators. They can step in to smooth things over without damaging your personal rapport with the buyer. Their neutrality often defuses tension quickly.
Ultimately, handling commissions while represented by a gallery requires balancing artistic freedom with business discipline. By involving your dealer, pricing accurately, documenting agreements, and communicating clearly, you turn potential stressors into profitable, positive experiences. Remember, a happy commission client is often your best advocate for future sales.
Do I have to pay my gallery a commission on private sales?
Typically, yes. Most gallery representation agreements stipulate that any sale made within a certain period (often 12 months) after a gallery introduction owes the gallery its standard commission. Even if the client contacts you directly, if they discovered you through the gallery, you likely owe them. Check your specific contract.
Who owns the copyright to a commissioned piece?
Unless you sign a specific transfer of rights, the artist retains the copyright. The client owns the physical object and the right to display it. They cannot reproduce the image for commercial goods (like prints or merchandise) without a separate licensing agreement.
How much deposit should I ask for?
A 50% non-refundable deposit is standard practice. This covers your initial material costs and secures the client's commitment. The remaining 50% is due before the work is shipped or delivered.
What if the client dislikes the final result?
If you followed the approved sketches and contract terms, you are generally not obligated to refund. However, offering a small discount or a free minor adjustment can preserve the relationship. Clear communication throughout the process minimizes this risk.
Should I handle shipping myself or through the gallery?
It depends on your agreement. Galleries often have preferred shippers and insurance rates. Using them simplifies billing and ensures the piece arrives in expected condition. If you ship directly, ensure you use insured, tracked services and provide the client with the tracking number immediately.